C.A.R. lender satisfaction survey finds short-sale process still broken;
lenders make no material improvement
Latest survey finds erosion in REALTORS®’ satisfaction with lendersLOS ANGELES (Aug. 3) – More REALTORS® characterized closing short-sale transactions as “difficult” or “extremely difficult” than late last year, indicating that lenders’ and servicers’ short-sale procedures have shown little improvement in the past six months, according to the latest Lender Satisfaction Survey conducted by the CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® (C.A.R.).
More than three-fourths (77 percent) of California REALTORS® reported closing short-sale transactions as “difficult” or “extremely difficult,” up from 70 percent in December, according to the C.A.R. survey. The survey, a follow-up to a survey conducted in December 2010, gauges REALTORS®’ experience working with lenders in their most recent transaction. The majority of those surveyed dealt with short-sale transactions – transactions in which a homeowner with a demonstrated hardship negotiates with the lender or lenders to accept less than the balance owed on the mortgage.
“Despite promises by lenders to improve their short-sale processes, clearly, they are not doing enough,” said C.A.R. President Beth L. Peerce. “Instead of helping struggling homeowners who need to sell and willing home buyers who want to buy, lenders have created man-made roadblocks that have caused real estate gridlock and hindered a desperately needed housing recovery.”
REALTORS® continued to cite communication issues as the most frequent obstacles in working with lenders and servicers during the short-sale process. These communication issues include lenders’ slow response time to a short-sale package (cited by 66 percent of REALTORS®), poor communication with lender representatives (cited by 55 percent of REALTORS®), and repeated requests for documentation (cited by 51 percent of REALTORS®). More than 15 percent of REALTORS® indicated that the lender foreclosed on the home before the short-sale transaction could be completed.
Two-thirds (67 percent) of REALTORS® said it took more than 60 days for lenders or servicers to return a written response on the approval or disapproval of the short-sale agreement submitted. Additionally, 43 percent of REALTORS® said it took the lender more than five days to return any form of communication. Less than 20 percent said lenders responded “within one business day” or less.
Overall satisfaction with the lenders REALTORS® worked with in their most recent short-sale transaction remained extremely poor, with 75 percent saying they were “not satisfied” or “not at all satisfied,” up from 67 percent in December. Moreover, nearly eight in 10 REALTORS® (78 percent) said they were “not likely” or “not at all likely” to refer buyers to the lender for future home purchases.
“With short sales accounting for a fifth of all transactions in California, it’s crucial that lenders improve their short-sale process so that a meaningful recovery in the housing market and overall economy can occur,” Peerce added.
In an effort to educate consumers and its members about short sales, C.A.R. created a website (http://www.shortsalescalifornia.org/) earlier this spring to help clarify the process. The association recently polled its members via the website and asked them to rate which lender was the easiest to work with. Of the top four lenders, 40 percent said Wells Fargo was the easiest, while 23 percent cited Bank of America; 17 percent said JP Morgan Chase; and 11 percent said Citi.
C.A.R.’s Lender Satisfaction Survey was conducted in June 2011 to gauge REALTORS®’ experience in working with lenders or servicers during their most recent transaction, the majority of which were short sales. Most of the REALTORS® surveyed dealt with Bank of America, Wells Fargo, and JP Morgan Chase in their most recent transaction. The latest survey findings show that the situation has not materially improved in the six months since C.A.R. first surveyed its members.
Leading the way…® in California real estate for more than 100 years, the CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® (www.car.org) is one of the largest state trade organizations in the United States, with more than 160,000 members dedicated to the advancement of professionalism in real estate. C.A.R. is headquartered in Los Angeles.